The Liability for Breach of the Preliminary Contract
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.6918/IJOSSER.202506_8(6).0001Keywords:
The Preliminary Contract; Liability for Breach of Contract; the Civil Code.Abstract
The liability for breach of preliminary contract should not completely exclude the application of the enforcement of performance, but denying the application is supposed be taken as the principle, affirming it as the exception. When there is a dispute over the terms of liquidated damages and deposit, the provisions of the general contract law on them shall be applied. The amount of compensation for losses shall apply the compromise theory, considering the possibility of performance of the contract, the degree of achievement of the conditions for the conclusion of the contract and other factors.
Downloads
References
[1] Art 4 of Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on the Relevant Issues concerning the Application of Law for Trying Cases on Dispute over Contract for the Sale of Commodity Houses [Z], which was promulgated by State Council on 28 April 2003 and effective on 1 June 2003.
[2] Art 2 Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on Issues Concerning the Application of Law for the Trial of Cases of Disputes over Sales Contracts [Z], which was promulgated by the Supreme People’s Court on 10 March 2012 and effective on 1 July 2012.
[3] Art 495 of Civil Code of the People’s Republic of China, which was promulgated by the Third session of the 13th National People’s Congress of the People’s Republic of China on 28 March 2020 and effective on 1 January 2021)[Z] (Hereinafter “the Civil Code”).
[4] Art 6 Interpretation by the Supreme Peoples Court of Several Issues Concerning the Application of Title One General Provisions of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code of the People’s Republic of China [Z] , which was promulgated by the Supreme People’s Court on 4 December 2023 and effective immediately (Hereinafter “the Interpretation of General Provisions of Contracts”) .
[5] Fujian Putian Guangyuan Feed Corp Ltd v Chen Hua, unrep., No 935 of 2014 (The Supreme People’s Court, 19 Aug 2014 ) [EB/OL] Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=6FkEWTGhxSg6DpeTPvCAZ/sOZuX98I1/eN7xIXlxOeiTfrOKZnFnFvUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3IK4FxAsMuq+z1OsKqz+DLp (visited April 24 2025).
[6] Jiao Qingyang, “The Legal Structure and Legal Effect Determination of the Preliminary Contract[J]” (2016) 9 Shehui kexue(Social Science) p 107.
[7] Ye Qiongbiao, Mei Xiaying, “ Research on the Issue of the Preliminary Contract [J]” (2019) 4 Zhongguo shehui kexueyuan yanjiusheng xuebao (Journal of Graduate School of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences) pp 68-69.
[8] Liu Junchen, “ Exploration on some legal problems of contract appointment [J]” (2002) 4 Falv shiyong (Application of Law) p 36.
[9] See Melvin A. Eisenberg, Foundational Principles of Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2018) 295. Quoted from Lin Huanmin, “ The Deconstruction and Reconstruction of the Preliminary Pontract--Comment on Article 495 of the Civil Code [J]” (2020) 4 Beifang faxue (Northern Legal Science) p 19.
[10] Wang Hongliang, “ The Nature and Exercise of the Right of the Enforcement of Performance [J]” (2012) 1 Faxue (Law Science) p 105.
[11] China Mobile Communications Group Jiangsu Corp Ltd Nanjing Branch v Nanjing Guangming Real Estate Development Corp Ltd, Nanjing Tongda Urban Infrastructure Development Corp Ltd, unrep., No 35 of 2014 (Nanjing Intermediate People’s Court, 29 January 2015)[EB/OL] Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=/6bQ+HK0RivwTCe22rm8z3vo+/GV9k7Sv/To0j6QUqy+sRM1Es9fOPUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3L1x12yInWFBXfP53ZBvkPN (visited April 24 2025).
[12] Xin Chonghua, “ Confirmation and Termination of the Commercial house Sale Preliminary Contract [J]” (2015) 8 Renmin sifa (People’s Justice) p 106.
[13] Liang Huixing, “ Interpretation Rules for the Preliminary Contract--Article 2 of Interpretation of Sales Contracts Interpretation [2012] No. 8 [J/OL]”, Available at: http://iolaw.cssn.cn/zxzp/201211/t20121106_4618794.shtml (visited April 24 2025).
[14] Han Shiyuan, [General Contract Law][M] (Law Press, 2018) p 94, 609, 204, 95.
[15] Ye Feng, “The Way out of the Preliminary Contract--from the Perspective of the Construction of Type Series[J]” (2015) 9 Falv shiyong (Appliacation of Law) p 85.
[16] Zhang Yanling, Bai Bangwu, “ Discussion on Issues Related to the Preliminary Contract [J]” (2005) 2 Shandong shehui kexue (Shandong Social Science) p 92. Huang Zhengjiang, “Study on the Preliminary Contract [J]” (2002) 8 Guangxi zhengfa guanli ganbu xueyuan xuebao (Journal of Guangxi Administrative Cadre Institute of Political Science and Law) p 64, 57.
[17] Zhang Li v Xuzhou Tongli Real Estate Corp Ltd(2005), unrep., Guiding case No. 11 of 2012, (Quanshan District People’s Court of Xuzhou City, Jiangsu Province, 12 Apr 2011 )[EB/OL] Available at: http://gongbao.court.gov.cn/Details/7412288408c0c6ded637b38b364595.html (visited April 24 2025).
[18] The Leading Group of the Implementation Group of the Civil Code of the Supreme People’s Court (ed), “ [Understanding And Application of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code Of the People’ Republic of China][M] (People’s Court Press, 2021) p 747, 345.
[19] Zhu Guangxin classifies them into the following four categories: Debts of inaction; Debts for work or services of a personalized nature; When the consequences of the enforcement of performance would compel one party to continue a personal relationship; It is ethically unacceptable. See Zhu Guangxin, “[General Principles of Contract Law] [M]( People’s University of China Press, 2012) p 568. Han Shiyuan believes that the restrictions on the enforcement of performance of such objects are due to the consideration of personality respect and personal freedom, so the contracts with personal exclusivity as the main obligation, such as the commission contract, the technology development contract and the publishing contract, are not applicable to the direct enforcement. Huang Shaokun, “ (The Enforcement of Performance as a Form of Liability for Breach of Contract)[J]” (2019) 6 Gansu zhengfa xueyuan xuebao (Journal of Gansu College of Political Science and Law) p 64).
[20] Wen Xiaopeng, Wang Xia, “ The Application of the Enforcement of performance in the Preliminary Contract [J]” (2013) 9 Heihe xuekan (Journal of Heihe) p 89, 161.
[21] Shi Haoming, Cheng Jun, “ The Legal Effect and the Enforcement of Performance of the Preliminary Contract [J]” (2013) 5 Suzhou daxue xuebao (Journal of Soochow University) p 98. Shi Xiaoli, Mao Jianjun, “(Research on the Preliminary Contract System)[J]” (2006) 4 Sichuan shifan daxue xuebao (Journal of Sichuan Normal University) p 28.
[22] Lu Qing, “ (Analysis on Article 2 of ‘Judicial Interpretation of Sales Contracts’[J]” (2013) 3 Faxuejia (Jurist) p 123, 125.
[23] The Second Civil Trial Division and Research Office of the Supreme People’s Court (ed), [Judicial Interpretation and Application of Interpretation by the Supreme People’s Court of Several Issues Concerning the Application of Title One General Provisions of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code of the People’s Republic of China] [M]( People’ Court Press, 2023) p 115, 119, 122.
[24] Luo Kun, “ (The Theory of the Types of the Preliminary Contract from the functional perspective)[J]” (2022) 4 Faxuejia (Jurist) 91.
[25] Fujian Putian Guangyuan Feed Corp Ltd v Chen Hua, unrep., No 2606 of 2014 (Beijing Higher People’s Court, 19 Aug 2014 )[EB/OL] Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=6CvtfkzasvlP0QXWOTHXAWusNc20peWwhTR7giW5qblAXSLYx8qhAfUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3I8OOYeKC+2SRXBG2Qcy+ro (visited April 24 2025).
[26] Zhang Guha, “ (Research on the System of the Preliminary Contract--Centered on Article 2 of the Judicial Interpretation of Sales Contracts)[J]” (2015) 1 Shehui kexue yanjiu (Science Social Research) p 108. Wang Liming, “ (Study on Major and Difficult Problems in the Interpretation by the Supreme Peoples Court of Several Issues Concerning the Application of Title One General Provisions of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China)[J]” (2020) 1 Yunnan shehui kexue(Yunnan Social Science) p 81.
[27] Wang Liming, “ (Research on Some problems of the Preliminary Contract--Review of Relevant Provisions of Judicial Interpretation in China)[J]” (2014) 1 Fashang yanjiu (Study on Law and Business) p 60.
[28] Li Kaiguo, Zhang Xian, “ (On the Legal Effect of the Preliminary Contract and its Liability for Breach of Contract)[J]” (2011) 4 Henansheng zhengfa xueyuan xuebao(Journal of Henan Administrative Cadre Institute of Political Science and Law) p 110.
[29] Liu Chengwei, “ (Hierarchy Theory of the Preliminary Contract)[J]” (2013) 6 Faxue luntan (Legal Forum) p 36, 38.
[30] Chongqing Jinhuan Enterprise Port Investment Corp Ltd v Chongqing Blu-ray Real Estate Development Corp Ltd, unrep.[EB/OL], No 661 of 2018 (The Supreme People’s Court, 30 Sept 2018 ) Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=P83y7mkM3w0zKfP5QWsI0AQ/Meu8UPprlLVyXwj1a6UnazHNl6VMXPUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3I81dFThazKN/eQ+xNp0/lU (visited April 24 2025).
[31] Guo Zhiyong, “ (Study on the Trial Path of the Preliminary contract--Taking Commodity House Preliminary Contract as an Example)[J]” (2019) 4 Shenzhen shehui kexue (Shenzhen Social Sciences) p 145. Chen Junyang, “（The liability for breach of the Preliminary Contract）[J]” (2021) 2 Henan daxue xuebao (Journal of Henan University) p 35, 34.
[32] He Le He Zhong Real Estate Corp Ltd. v Hong Liang, unrep., No 5741 of 2022 (Foshan Intermediate People’s Court of Guangdong Province, 30 Nov 2022 ) [EB/OL]Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=yBQdAKheX77W0kUqUbBx6KD9eLFuhHMbHmLSYwzlkQTBKIV7WhfT1vUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3J/54saIf7Bo+qUAH4kRw4k (visited April 24 2025).
[33] Interpretation by the Supreme Peoples Court of Several Issues Concerning the Application of Title One General Provisions of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code of the People’s Republic of China (Draft))[Z] ,which was issued by China’s Supreme People’s Court on 4 Nov 2022.
[34] Ye Feng, “The Way out of the Preliminary Contract--from the Perspective of the Construction of Type Series[J]” (2015) 9 Falv shiyong (Appliacation of Law) p 86.
[35] Beijing Elegant Decoration Engineering Corp Ltd v Beijing Henry Day Art Furniture Corp Ltd, unrep., No 01756 of 2007 (Beijing Second Intermediate People’s Court, 19 Mar 2007 ) [EB/OL]<https://www-pkulaw-com-443.webvpn.cfau.edu.cn/pfnl/a25051f3312b07f3d60af6d52058cab5a275542f1070e91abdfb.html?keyword=%EF%BC%882007%EF%BC%89%E4%BA%8C%E4%B8%AD%E6%B0%91%E7%BB%88%E5%AD%9701756%E5%8F%B7&way=listView#anchor-documentno> (visited April 24 2025).
[36] Zhang Suhua. Zhang Yuchen, “ (The Standard Construction of the Preliminary Contract system in the Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code)[J]” (2020) 1 Shehui kexue (Social Science) p 120.
[37] Wang RuiLing, “ (The Subjective Interpretation Theory of Distinction and Cohesion between Preliminary Pontract and Contract--and the Discussion of Objective Interpretation Theory)[J]” (2016)10 Zhengzhi yu falv (Politics and Law) p 158.
[38] Zhuang Jing v Beijing Changjiu Shida Automobile Sales Corp Ltd, unrep., No 5741 of 2022 (Beijing Second Intermediate People 's Court, 31 Aug 2022 )[EB/OL] Available at: https://wenshu.court.gov.cn/website/wenshu/181107ANFZ0BXSK4/index.html?docId=0iKNW5yGV8IsxgOPBBMygwd93s62Wdrqcp+1QguGWLRndx67m9zwbPUKq3u+IEo4WOWovqKa/FObqMR5MgqiIReBRrY5CIL7b3/5AokZJ3JANRHP5IqgeQfy69awmnJH> (visited April 24 2025).
[39] Lin Huanmin, “ (The Deconstruction and Reconstruction of the Preliminary Pontract--Comment on Article 495 of the Civil Code)[J]” (2020) 4 Beifang faxue (Northern Legal Science) p 29.
[40] Qian Yulin, “ (Preliminary Discussion on the Preliminary Contract)[J]” (2023) 8 Gansu zhengfa daxue xuebao (Journal of Gansu Institute of Political Science and Law) p 4.
[41] Cao Canru v Shanghai Rhines Real Estate Corp Ltd, unrep.[EB/OL], No 609 of 2010 (Shanghai Second Intermediate People’s Court, 15 Oct 2010 ) <https://www-pkulaw-com-443.webvpn.cfau.edu.cn/pfnl/a25051f3312b07f3c216302090b15412d9b628df162cd64dbdfb.html?keyword=%EF%BC%882010%EF%BC%89%E6%B2%AA%E4%BA%8C%E4%B8%AD%E6%B0%91%E4%BA%8C%28%E6%B0%91%29%E7%BB%88%E5%AD%97%E7%AC%AC609%E5%8F%B7&way=listView#anchor-documentno> (visited April 24 2025).
[42] Tang Wenping, “(Perfecting Suggestion on the draft of Interpretation by the Supreme Peoples Court of Several Issues Concerning the Application of Title One General Provisions of Book Three Contracts of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China) [J/OL]”, available at https://law.jnu.edu.cn/2022/1118/c1235a728929/page.htm (visited April 24 2025).
[43] Sui Xiaopeng, “ (Understanding of the Preliminary Contract in the Civil Code)[N]” People's Court News (6 August 2020) p 7.
[44] Zhong Chongqing v Shanghai Jinxuan Dadi Real Estate Project Development Corp Ltd, unrep.[EB/OL], No 1125 of 2007 (Shanghai Second Intermediate People 's Court, 18 May 2005 ) Available at: http://gongbao.court.gov.cn/Details/04ecf4266ba61159202bbd36a9d80b.html(visited April 24 2025).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 International Journal of Social Science and Education Research
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
